Professional Conversations
Breaking bad news, difficult consultations, colleague discussions and communication skills.
Last reviewed
Professional Conversations are some of the most feared SCA stations β and the easiest to lose marks on if you treat them like a normal consultation. The person in front of you is usually a colleague, relative, or member of staff, not a patient. Use this guide to learn the structure, language, and frameworks that examiners are looking for. Then put it into practice with our featured case below or on the SCA case generator and AI Actors.

Workplace Sexual Harassment
Case 14 Β· Priya Malik Β· 30 Β· Practice Nurse
Priya, your practice nurse, has booked an urgent confidential meeting outside her normal hours. She wants to talk to you about Dr Rowe β a senior partner. Comments on her appearance. A hand on her lower back. A late-night WhatsApp message with a kiss. She is frightened. She isn't even sure if it "counts".
This is one of the highest-yield Professional Conversation scenarios in the SCA. To pass, you must name the behaviour as harassment, validate Priya's experience, present clear options (Practice Manager, Freedom to Speak Up Guardian, ACAS, RCN), preserve her autonomy β while being transparent about your own duty to act if patient safety is at risk.
Table of Contents
1What is a Professional Conversation in the SCA?
In a Professional Conversation station, the person in the chair with you is not a patient seeking medical care. They are a colleague, a relative, a staff member, or someone raising a concern. The clinical content is light. The marks are in how you communicate, how you handle uncertainty, and whether you uphold your professional duties.
Visual explanation
Listen first, then agree what happens next

Make space to speak
Use a private setting, an open invitation and attentive listening. Explore the concern and its impact.
Make the plan clear
Summarise what you heard and agree actions, who will take them and when to review.
Remember: Respect and collaboration help someone raise a concern. Explore what support they want, explain any duty to act and check their understanding of the next steps.
Illustrative conversation sequence. Sources: GMC: colleagues, culture and safety
These stations test
- β’ Active listening and empathy under pressure
- β’ Recognising and naming difficult truths
- β’ Knowledge of NHS structures (FtSU, GMC, ACAS, unions)
- β’ Balancing autonomy with duty to act
- β’ Plain-English explanation of process and law
These stations are NOT
- β’ A clinical consultation β don't take a history of presenting complaint
- β’ A chance to diagnose or prescribe β they are not your patient
- β’ A place for vague reassurance ("I'm sure he didn't mean it")
- β’ A negotiation β examiners want clarity, not fudging
2How Examiners Mark This Station
The same three SCA domains apply β but they look different in a Professional Conversation. Knowing what the examiner is ticking under each heading is the single most useful thing you can revise.
Data Gathering
Get the full chronology in the person's own words. Specific incidents (when, what was said, was anyone else present?). Frequency. Escalation. Impact on wellbeing, on work, and β crucially β on patient safety. Ask if anyone else has experienced the same.
Clinical Management (the "professional" equivalent)
Name the issue clearly using the right language (harassment, bullying, probity, fitness to practise). Present a menu of escalation routes β internal (Practice Manager, senior partner, FtSU Guardian) and external (ACAS, RCN, BMA, GMC, police). Preserve evidence. Document. Be transparent about your own duty to escalate where there is a safety risk.
Relating to Others
Make the room feel safe. Acknowledge the courage it took to speak up. Validate the experience β don't minimise. Match the person's pace. Avoid promises you cannot keep, especially around confidentiality. Agree clear next steps and a follow-up.
3Common Scenarios in the Exam
Professional Conversation scenarios cluster around a small number of recognisable patterns. If you have rehearsed each one, you will recognise it within the first minute of the station.
Workplace harassment or bullying
A nurse, receptionist, or trainee raises concerns about a colleague β often a senior. Equality Act, Freedom to Speak Up, evidence preservation.
Concerns about a colleague
Performance, intoxication, mental health, or possible probity issues. GMC duty to act balanced with collegial support.
Whistleblowing & FtSU
Someone wants to raise a concern but fears repercussions. Explain the protections under the Employment Rights Act 1996 and the FtSU Guardian role.
Breaking bad news
To a relative, often by phone. SPIKES framework, warning shot, silence, signposting to bereavement support.
Receiving a complaint
A patient or relative complains about you, a partner, or the practice. Listen, apologise for the experience, explain the process, escalate per policy.
Difficult team conversation
A trainee, ANP, or partner needs feedback or escalation about behaviour, dress code, or boundaries. Calibrate honesty with respect.
4A Structure That Works
Most candidates fail Professional Conversations because they go in without a structure and start improvising. Use the same seven-step skeleton for every scenario β it is short, defensible, and naturally hits the marker tickboxes.
- 1
Set up safety
Confirm the space is private, time-protected, and that the person is comfortable. Acknowledge the courage of being there.
- 2
Open and explore
Use an open invitation: βTell me whatβs been happening.β Then chronology, frequency, specifics, witnesses, evidence.
- 3
Validate and name it
Acknowledge the impact, then label the issue accurately (harassment, bullying, fitness-to-practise concern, complaint).
- 4
Explore impact and ICE
Wellbeing, sleep, work, patient safety. Ideas (what they think it is), Concerns (especially about repercussions), Expectations (what they want from you).
- 5
Present a menu of options
Internal first, external second. Lay them out neutrally so the person can choose, while making clear what you would recommend.
- 6
Be transparent about your duties
You cannot promise total confidentiality if patient safety is involved. Say so up front, kindly.
- 7
Agree a plan and safety-net
Concrete next step, who does what by when, how to escalate if it gets worse, when you will meet again.
5Workplace Sexual Harassment & the Equality Act 2010
The Equality Act 2010 defines sexual harassment as unwanted conduct of a sexual nature that has the purpose or effect of violating the recipient's dignity, or of creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating, or offensive environment.
Key principles
- β’ Behaviour does not have to be physical or explicit β comments, messages, and personal-space invasion all qualify.
- β’ Intent is irrelevant. The test is the impact on the recipient.
- β’ A single serious incident can be harassment; a pattern of lesser incidents certainly is.
- β’ The employer has a duty to prevent harassment β failure creates vicarious liability.
Critical exam action
Name it. Candidates who skirt around the word "harassment" routinely fail this station. Once the facts are clear, say it plainly: "What you're describing is sexual harassment under the Equality Act."
Practise this live: Case 14 (Priya Malik) is the canonical SCA-style harassment scenario. She presents unsure if it counts. Your job is to know that it does, and to say so β kindly but clearly. Practice with Priya
6Whistleblowing & Freedom to Speak Up
You will not be expected to recite legislation, but examiners reward candidates who can name the right route when a colleague is afraid to speak up.
Freedom to Speak Up Guardian
Every NHS organisation in England must have one. Their job is to support staff to raise concerns confidentially and safely. They are independent of line management. This is usually the first answer the examiners want when a colleague is too frightened to go to the practice manager.
Public Interest Disclosure Act / Employment Rights Act 1996
Workers who raise a "protected disclosure" about wrongdoing in good faith are legally protected from detriment or dismissal. You don't have to recite the act β saying "there are legal protections for raising concerns, often called whistleblowing protections" is enough.
External routes to know by name
- β’ ACAS β free, confidential workplace advice line
- β’ RCN / Unison / BMA β relevant trade union for representation
- β’ GMC β when concerns relate to a doctor's fitness to practise
- β’ CQC β for systemic concerns about care quality or safety
- β’ NHS England / ICB β for primary-care contractor-level issues
- β’ Police β if behaviour escalates to criminal harassment, stalking, or assault
7Breaking Bad News: The SPIKES Framework
SPIKES is the most reliable framework for breaking bad news in the SCA β whether to a patient, a relative, or by telephone. Examiners are listening for the warning shot and silence; many candidates miss both.
Setting
Private space. Sit down. Phones away. Tissues. Ask if they want anyone present. On the phone: confirm identity, confirm they are alone or with support, confirm a safe place to talk.
Perception
βCan you tell me what you understand so far?β Find out what they already know β never assume.
Invitation
βHow much would you like me to tell you?β Some people want everything; some want headlines. Calibrate to their preference.
Knowledge
Fire a warning shot: βIβm afraid I have some difficult news.β Pause. Use plain language. Avoid euphemisms (βpassed awayβ is acceptable; βlost the battleβ is not). Chunk and check.
Emotions
Acknowledge the silence. Do not fill it. Reflect what you see: βThis is devastating news.β Empathy is rewarded heavily here.
Strategy & Summary
Outline what happens next, in plain English. Offer a follow-up call. Signpost bereavement support (Cruse, GP, faith leader). Document carefully.
8Concerns About a Colleague's Performance or Health
The classic scenario: a partner appears to be drinking on shift, a trainee is making medication errors, a colleague's mental health is visibly affecting their consultations. The GMC's Good Medical Practice is unambiguous β you must act if patient safety is at risk. The skill is doing it kindly and proportionately.
Do
- β’ Talk to your colleague first if it is safe and proportionate
- ⒠Approach with concern, not accusation: "I've noticed⦠are you okay?"
- β’ Document what you have observed contemporaneously, with dates
- β’ Escalate to a partner / training programme director / responsible officer
- β’ Signpost: Practitioner Health Programme, BMA Counselling, their own GP
- β’ Refer to GMC if patient safety is at risk and local steps fail
Don't
- β’ Discuss it with other colleagues informally β that's gossip, not action
- β’ Cover for them out of misplaced loyalty
- β’ Try to be their treating doctor β that's a boundary breach
- β’ Confront them in front of patients or other staff
- β’ Promise to keep it to yourself if patients may be at risk
9Receiving and Responding to a Complaint
A patient or relative is angry. They may be complaining about you, a partner, or the system. Your job in the SCA is to de-escalate, listen, apologise where appropriate, and explain the formal process β without becoming defensive or accepting liability you cannot speak to.
Visual explanation
A clear first response to a complaint
1
Listen and clarify
Hear the concern without interrupting. Ask what matters most and what outcome the person hopes for.
2
Acknowledge and apologise
Recognise the impact. Offer a sincere apology when something has gone wrong.
3
Explain honestly
Say what is known and what still needs investigation. Explain the local complaints process.
4
Agree and follow up
Clarify actions, a named contact and an agreed response timescale. Record and follow up the discussion.
Remember: Respond promptly and openly. Do not speculate, promise an outcome before investigation or let a complaint affect the personβs care. Address any immediate safety concern as soon as it is identified.
Simplified teaching diagram. Sources: CQC: complaints management in general practice Β· GMC: openness and honesty when things go wrong
The duty of candour (Regulation 20)
Where a notifiable safety incident has caused harm, providers must be open and honest: tell the patient, apologise, explain what is known, offer reasonable support, follow it up in writing. An apology is not an admission of liability β say sorry without hesitation.
- 1Listen to the complaint in full without interrupting. Most of the work is done here.
- 2Apologise for the experience: βIβm really sorry that this has happened to you.β
- 3Acknowledge feelings. Validate without minimising or making excuses.
- 4Explain the formal complaints process: in-house first (Practice Manager), then PHSO / ICB, with timelines.
- 5Offer practical next steps: a meeting, a written response, signposting to PALS or the ICB.
- 6Document the conversation contemporaneously. Notify your indemnifier early if it concerns you personally.
10Phrases That Score Marks
Memorise three or four of these. They map directly to examiner tickboxes for empathy, validation, transparency, and shared decision-making.
βThank you for coming to me. I can see this has taken courage. Whatever you tell me, Iβll take seriously. Please take your time.β
βTell me whatβs been happening, in your own words. Start wherever feels right.β
βWhat youβre describing is not okay, and it isnβt your fault.β
βUnder the Equality Act, harassment is defined by its impact on you, not his intent.β
βThere are legal protections for raising concerns of this kind β you should not face any detriment for speaking up.β
βI want to be honest with you β if I become worried that patient safety is at risk, I may have a duty to escalate. But Iβll always tell you first.β
βThere are a few routes we can take. Internally we haveβ¦ and externally we haveβ¦ Which of those feels right for you?β
βIβm afraid I have some difficult news to share with you.β
β(after a pause) Take all the time you need. Iβm here.β
βIβm really sorry that this has been your experience. That should not have happened.β
βLetβs meet again next week to see how youβre doing and decide on next steps together. If anything escalates before then, please contact me right away.β
11Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Failing to name the issue. Saying βthat sounds difficultβ without naming harassment / bullying / a fitness-to-practise concern is a near-automatic loss of marks.
- Treating the colleague as a patient. Donβt take a clinical history of their anxiety. Signpost them to their own GP.
- Promising absolute confidentiality. You may have a duty to escalate. Be transparent about that up front.
- Trying to mediate or confront the perpetrator on the colleagueβs behalf. That is not the GPβs role.
- Minimising. βIβm sure he didnβt mean anything by itβ invalidates the experience and is heavily penalised.
- Forgetting patient safety. If a colleagueβs distraction or behaviour might affect care, address it explicitly.
- No safety-net or follow-up. Leaving the conversation open-ended is a missed mark for management.
- Filling silence after bad news. Sit with it. Examiners are watching whether you can.
- Skipping documentation. Mention it: βIβll document this conversation contemporaneously.β

Ready to put this into practice?
Priya is waiting. Walk into the conversation with the structure from Section 4, the language from Section 10, and find out how it actually feels to handle this in real time.
Start Case 14Useful sources
- β’ GMC β Good Medical Practice (2024 edition)
- β’ National Guardian's Office β Freedom to Speak Up
- β’ Equality and Human Rights Commission β Sexual harassment and harassment at work: technical guidance
- β’ ACAS β Discrimination, bullying and harassment
- β’ CQC β Regulation 20: Duty of candour
- β’ NHS Practitioner Health β confidential support for clinicians
Related Topics
Professional Dilemmas and Complaints
Ethical dilemmas, handling complaints, fitness to practise and professional boundaries.
Adults and Child Safeguarding
Safeguarding vulnerable adults and children, recognising abuse and making referrals.
Explaining Investigation Results
Giving blood, imaging and screening results in plain English: abnormal LFTs, anaemia, thyroid, HbA1c, kidney function, PSA and incidental findings.







